For the 1996 Cincinnati game vs. 1990 Florida State (baseball) game we had to go through several avenues to find the winner. The voting was tied on the site so we took to twitter where, well, it was tied again. So we decided to have an internal vote where we nearly came out tied again, but after the dust settled the '96 Cincy game barely escapes to the semi-finals.
The semifinals will begin on Thursday with 1980 Bama (football) vs. 1999 Egg Bowl. On Friday, we'll have the second matchup: 1996 Cincy vs. 2004 Bama (basketball).